A Florida jury has sentenced Dwain Hall to life in prison for the kidnap and first-degree murder of Sonia Exelby. The 32-year-old British music teacher was found guilty of the crimes following a unanimous verdict on Friday 20 November 2026. Prosecutors argued that Hall targeted the victim because of her mental health struggles.
Dwain Hall has been sentenced to life in prison following a unanimous jury verdict on Friday 20 November 2026. The 54-year-old was found guilty of kidnapping and first-degree murder involving Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music teacher from Portsmouth. The decision follows a trial regarding the death of the British national in the United States.
The prosecution argued that Hall took advantage of Exelby because she was mentally ill and incapable of making rational decisions. Investigators alleged that Hall was aware of her mental health struggles and used them to lure her to Florida. Authorities stated that Exelby boarded a flight to the US with the apparent intention of being sexually abused, tortured, and murdered by unknown individuals.
The legal proceedings concluded after Hall had pleaded not guilty to the charges. During the trial, Hall's legal team did not call any defence witnesses and Hall himself did not give evidence, according to The Independent. The verdict marks the end of the criminal trial for the Florida mechanic and roadside assistance company owner.
Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt stated that Hall used a knife to stab Exelby four times. According to Amy Berndt, the wounds were between four and seven inches deep. The prosecution's case highlighted the violent nature of the attack on the 32-year-old teacher.
The murder weapon was later found to have Exelby's blood on it. According to The Independent, Hall had sent the weapon to a friend in Ohio for safekeeping. This evidence formed part of the case presented to the jury during the trial.
The prosecution also highlighted Hall's digital activity during the period surrounding the crime. The Independent reported that Hall had asked Google's AI assistant how long it would take a large family dog to decompose just days before the body was found. Investigators also found images of the torture, rape, and mutilation of women on Hall's phone.
Sonia Exelby was noted as being absent from her residence on 12 October 2025, according to The Independent. This triggered a search that eventually led investigators to Marion County, Florida. On 17 October 2025, her body was discovered in a shallow grave, according to The Independent.
Police were able to trace Hall by using the credit card belonging to the victim. This card was used by the roadside assistance company that Hall owned. This link helped investigators connect Hall to the missing British teacher.
Hall, who was an auto repair and tow truck driver according to The Guardian, was subsequently identified as a person of interest. The investigation into her disappearance and death eventually led to the charges brought against him in the Florida court system.
The prosecution detailed how Hall met Exelby through a fetish website. According to The Independent, Hall used the online identity 'Alpha Sadist' to communicate with her. His biography on the site stated that he wanted complete control over a 'domestic pain slut'.
Investigators believe this online interaction was used to manipulate the victim. The prosecution's case suggested that Hall used these digital platforms to target Exelby specifically because of her mental health. This grooming process was a central component of the prosecution's claims regarding the motive for the kidnap.
Exelby had a history of self-harm and previous suicide attempts. Authorities suggested that Hall used this background to facilitate his plan to lure her to the United States. The intersection of the online grooming and her mental health was a key focus of the trial.
During the trial, Hall's lawyer, Junior Barrett, argued that Exelby's trip to the US was motivated by a desire to end her life. He suggested to the court that she may have stabbed herself. This was part of the defence's attempt to contest the murder charges.
Junior Barrett stated, "She came here with the intention of dying, she thought she was worthless, useless, a burden on other people.", according to The Guardian. The defence team's strategy focused on the victim's mental state and her reasons for travelling to Florida.
Despite these arguments, the jury returned a guilty verdict. Hall's legal team chose not to call any witnesses to provide testimony during the proceedings. The jury ultimately rejected the suggestion that the death was self-inflicted or not the result of Hall's actions.
The death of the music teacher has caused significant distress to her relatives in the UK. Barry Wilton, the brother of Sonia Exelby, spoke about the impact of the loss on his family. He described the past year as one of the most difficult periods they have faced.
"This last year has been one of the hardest of our lives. Losing our dear sister Sonia has had a profound impact on me and my entire family. I’m not sure we will ever be the same again.", said Barry Wilton, Sonia Exelby's brother.
Amy Berndt, the prosecutor, also commented on the victim's character and the tragedy of her death. She said, "She was beautiful. She was kind and she was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. And she also suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She should be alive today."
Answers are written by AI and may be wrong - for anything important, use the contact page.