Court Room

Surgeon Wins Race Discrimination Claims Against NHS Trust

Mr U Butt won his claims of direct and indirect race discrimination against Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust. The tribunal awarded him a total of £63,939.61 for past financial losses and £25,000 for injury to feelings.

What happened

Mr U Butt was a consultant orthopaedic surgeon at Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust from 17 August 2015 until 9 July 2024. The tribunal heard that Mr Butt applied for the role of chair of the surgery division within the Salford care organisation.

The tribunal found that Mr Butt attended an interview on 23 January 2024. During the interview, he received scores from the panel. Dr Kellett scored him 25 and Dr Saunders scored him 23 after correcting an error. Despite these scores, the tribunal found that Mr Butt was not appointed to the role.

The tribunal heard that on 24 January 2024, Dr Kellett told Ms Victoria Dickens via text that the panel was "Still deliberating". On 25 January 2024, Ms Charlotte Bailey told Mr Butt there was a ninety-nine % likelihood he would be appointed to a chair role. However, the tribunal found that Ms Bailey later informed him of a decision not to appoint him, which the tribunal found was misleading.

Mr Butt resigned on 9 April 2024 and raised a grievance alleging race discrimination on 2 July 2024. The tribunal found that there was no evidence of a grievance hearing, a decision, or a right of appeal. The tribunal also heard that the respondent's initial response contained an untrue statement that Mr Butt had been scored below the agreed threshold for appointment.

What the tribunal decided

The tribunal found that the claim of direct race discrimination succeeded. The judge said the respondent had not shown that the decision not to appoint Mr Butt was in no way because of his race. The tribunal found that the respondent tried to argue that Mr Butt's ability to hold his parent specialty to account was a reason for not appointing him, but the tribunal found this was not a genuine reason. The tribunal also found that Mr Butt met all of the essential requirements of the role.

The tribunal also found that the claim of indirect discrimination succeeded. The judge said the respondent applied certain PCPs that allowed interview panels to depart from the scoring threshold. The tribunal heard that an equality, diversity and inclusion report stated "white candidates are 1.86 times more likely to be appointed compared to BME candidates". The tribunal further found that the evidence from the respondent's witnesses about the decision was contradictory and they could not be relied upon.

The tribunal found that the respondent unreasonably failed to comply with the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. The tribunal also found that Mr Butt suffered injury to feelings. As the tribunal was deciding both liability and remedy, the compensation was awarded at this stage.

The money

  • Compensation for past financial losses: £63,939.61
  • Interest on compensation for past financial losses: £6,958.03
  • Injury to feelings (increased by 25% Acas uplift): £25,000
  • Interest on injury to feelings: £5,441.10

What this means for you

This case shows how legal protections work to prevent discrimination in the workplace. It demonstrates that employers must follow fair processes when making decisions and handling formal complaints.

If you believe you have been treated unfairly at work, you can get free and impartial advice from Acas. They can help you understand your rights and the different ways to resolve a dispute with an employer.

Jargon buster

  • Acas: The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service: a free, impartial public body that advises on problems at work and helps employers and workers settle disputes.
  • Acas uplift: An increase of up to 25% in compensation when an employer unreasonably failed to follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
  • Claimant: The person who brings the claim, usually the worker or former worker.
  • Direct race discrimination: Being treated less favourably because of race.
  • Indirect discrimination: A rule or practice that applies to everyone but puts people with a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage, and that the employer cannot justify.
  • Injury to feelings: Compensation for the upset and distress caused by discrimination.
  • Interest: Tribunals can add interest to discrimination awards to make up for the time the money has been owed.
  • Liability: Whether the employer is legally responsible: in other words, whether the claim succeeds.
  • PCPs: Practices, policies or provisions.
  • Remedy: What the tribunal orders when a claim succeeds, usually compensation.
  • Respondent: The employer, or other person or organisation, the claim is made against.

About this case

Case number: 6004669/2024
Claimant: Mr U Butt
Respondent: Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust
Tribunal: Employment Tribunal, Manchester (Employment Judge Phil Allen)
Decision date: 13 October 2026

Read the full decision on GOV.UK

Topics: race discrimination, employment tribunal, nhs

This report explains a published tribunal decision in plain English. It is general information, not legal advice.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.