Court Room

Worker Wins Unauthorised Deduction of Wages Claim Against Royal Borough of Greenwich

Mr G A Khan brought several claims against the Royal Borough of Greenwich, including unfair dismissal and disability discrimination. The tribunal found in favour of Mr Khan regarding an unauthorised deduction of wages, but rejected all his other claims.

What happened

Mr G A Khan began his employment with the Royal Borough of Greenwich on 1 April 2019. He worked as a Team Leader in the Youth Offending Service at the Woolwich Centre. The tribunal heard that his role involved attending Saturday court on a rotating basis.

The tribunal heard that Mr Khan experienced several changes in his direct line management during his early employment. Between April 2019 and January 2020, he was managed by different people. According to the tribunal's findings, he was managed by Mr Aruliah in April 2019, then by Mr Andrews from May 2019 until mid-July 2019. After a period where he had no line manager, Mr Andrews resumed management in September 2019, followed by Ms Hunt from October 2019 to mid-January 2020.

Regarding the support provided, the tribunal found that Mr Khan was not unsupported during this period. The tribunal accepted that Mr Khan was an experienced worker and therefore did not require as much support as a new starter would.

The tribunal also addressed a procedural issue regarding the disclosure of documents. The tribunal found that the respondent had failed to disclose a document and was in breach of an earlier order for disclosure. However, the tribunal decided that the respondent's behaviour did not approach the level of becoming "scandalous or vexatious". The tribunal concluded that a fair trial was still possible and decided that no further sanction was necessary for the late disclosure. The tribunal decided to accept the supplementary bundle at face value regarding the forwarded email.

What the tribunal decided

The tribunal's decision focused on several different claims brought by Mr Khan. The tribunal found that the claim of unauthorised deduction of wages, in respect of pay between November 2021 and June 2022, was well founded. The tribunal stated, "The claim of unauthorised deduction of wages contrary to section 13 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 is well founded, and it succeeds."

However, the tribunal found that all other claims were not well founded. Mr Khan's claims for constructive unfair dismissal, direct race discrimination, and direct disability discrimination all failed. The tribunal also dismissed claims regarding discrimination arising from disability, indirect disability discrimination, and the failure to make reasonable adjustments.

Additionally, the tribunal rejected claims of harassment on the grounds of race or disability, victimisation, and detriment resulting from making health and safety disclosures. The tribunal stated, "All other claims are not well founded, and so they fail."

The money

  • Overpayment (gross): £6,73.34
  • Overpayment (net): £4,001.42
  • Overpayment (gross): £3,810.63

What this means for you

This case shows that workers have legal protections regarding the pay they receive. If an employer fails to pay the correct amount or withholds pay that a worker is entitled to, they may be able to claim for an unauthorised deduction of wages.

It is important to know that employment rights apply to various situations in the workplace. If a worker has concerns about their treatment or their pay, there are organisations available to help.

Anyone with a problem at work can get free, impartial advice from Acas.

Jargon buster

  • Acas: The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service: a free, impartial public body that advises on problems at work and helps employers and workers settle disputes.
  • Claimant: The person who brings the claim, usually the worker or former worker.
  • Constructive dismissal: When an employee resigns because the employer seriously broke their contract, the law can treat the resignation as a dismissal.
  • Detriment: Unfair treatment that puts someone at a disadvantage at work, short of dismissal.
  • Direct race discrimination: Being treated unfairly because of your race.
  • Disability: In the Equality Act 2010, a physical or mental impairment with a substantial and long-term effect on a person's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.
  • Discrimination arising from disability: Treating a disabled person unfavourably because of something linked to their disability, such as sickness absence, unless the employer can justify it.
  • Harassment: Unwanted conduct related to a protected characteristic, or of a sexual nature, that violates someone's dignity or creates an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.
  • Reasonable adjustments: Changes an employer must make so that a disabled worker is not put at a substantial disadvantage, such as different hours, duties or equipment.
  • Respondent: The employer, or other person or organisation, the claim is made against.
  • Unfair dismissal: Being dismissed without a fair reason, or in an unfair way. Most employees need to have worked for a minimum period to claim it.
  • Unlawful deduction from wages: Taking money out of someone's pay without the right to, or not paying wages that were due.
  • Victimisation: Treating someone badly because they complained about discrimination, or helped someone else who did.
  • Well-founded: The tribunal's phrase for a claim that succeeds. "Not well-founded" means it fails.

About this case

Case number: 2303101/2022
Claimant: Mr G A Khan
Respondent: Royal Borough of Greenwich
Tribunal: Employment Tribunal, London South (Employment Judge Atkins)
Decision date: 23 October 2026

Read the full decision on GOV.UK

Topics: breach of contract, disability discrimination, race discrimination, unfair dismissal, unlawful deduction from wages, working time regulations

This report explains a published tribunal decision in plain English. It is general information, not legal advice.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.