WPF News

The Court Room

Tribunal and court cases explained in plain English

Real cases, plain words

The Court Room explains real employment tribunal decisions in plain English: what happened, what the tribunal decided, any money awarded, and what the legal words mean.

The cases come from the decisions the employment tribunals publish on GOV.UK. New case reports appear here most days, each one checked against the full judgment and linked to it, so you can read the decision for yourself. 

The reports say what the tribunal found and decided. They are general information, not legal advice. If you have a problem at work, Acas gives free, impartial advice: acas.org.uk or 0300 123 1100.

Case reports

The latest cases

A row of buses parked in a lot during sunset

Mechanical Engineer Wins Claims for Unpaid Wages and Holiday Against Metroline Travel Limited

Mr D Calder brought several claims against Metroline Travel Limited, including unfair dismissal and discrimination. The tribunal ruled that the respondent had breached working time regulations and failed to pay owed wages and holiday entitlement.

A view looking down the deck of a large ship

Mr S Donnelly Succeeds in Disability Discrimination and Unfair Dismissal Claims Against DFDS (Guernsey) Limited

Mr S Donnelly brought claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal against DFDS (Guernsey) Limited. The tribunal found in favour of the claimant on all his claims and awarded him a total of £47,089.22.

An empty lounge area with cafe tables and seating

Cambridge Students' Union Worker Partially Succeeds in Race Harassment Claim, Tribunal Rules

Mr M Mumisa brought claims of race discrimination and harassment against the Cambridge Students' Union. The employment tribunal found that while his direct discrimination claim failed, his claim for race-related harassment regarding an incident in June 2024 succeeded.

Metal lattice towers in heavy fog

Installer's Claims Against BFT Mastclimbing Limited Succeed, Tribunal Rules

Mr Nathaniel Psaila has won his claims against BFT Mastclimbing Limited for unfair dismissal and detriment following protected disclosures. This judgment decides both liability and remedy, with the tribunal awarding a total of £25,392.56.

Empty university classroom with rows of wooden desks and a green chalkboard

Professor’s Claims For Discrimination And Unfair Dismissal Against The Open University Succeed

Joanna Phoenix brought claims of discrimination and unfair dismissal against The Open University. The tribunal found that several of her claims succeeded, including direct discrimination, harassment and constructive unfair dismissal. This judgment decided whether the claims succeeded; it did not decide compensation.

A row of blue metal lockers in a hallway with a wooden bench

Thames Valley Police Must Pay Officer Over Disability Discrimination Claims

Ms K Hibbert won her disability discrimination claims against The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police. Following a hearing, the tribunal decided that the officer was entitled to a total compensation award of £1,176,368.

Fabric rolls on wooden racks in a workshop or warehouse

Administrator Wins Unfair Dismissal Claim Against Vale Curtains and Blinds

Ms M Jones brought an unfair dismissal claim against Vale Curtains and Blinds. The employment tribunal found that the dismissal was unfair and awarded Ms Jones a total of £5,484.74. This judgment covers both the employer's liability and the resulting remedy.

Empty modern office with rows of desks and computer monitors

Employment Tribunal Rules in Favour of Worker in Unfair Dismissal Claim Against Interaction Recruitment Specialists Ltd

Ms N Hanson brought claims for unfair dismissal and unauthorised deduction from wages against Interaction Recruitment Specialists Ltd. The employment tribunal in Leeds found that the claimant's claims for unfair dismissal and certain unpaid wages succeeded, although one claim regarding a bonus and health insurance failed.

An empty train station platform with tracks and a bench at sunset

Train Driver Wins Unfair And Wrongful Dismissal Claim Against West Midlands Trains

Mr J. Richardson brought claims of unfair and wrongful dismissal against West Midlands Trains Ltd. The employment tribunal found in favour of the claimant and awarded him compensation for his lost earnings and benefits.

Yellow cleaning trolley in a bright, empty corridor

Cleaner's Claims Against Mitie Ltd Fail at Employment Tribunal

Mr A Depala brought claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against Mitie Ltd at the employment tribunal in Reading. The tribunal dismissed all of his claims, finding that his dismissal for gross misconduct was a reasonable response.

Warehouse aisles with wooden pallets on metal shelving units

Tribunal Rejects Former Amazon Worker's Unfair and Wrongful Dismissal Claims

Mrs A Gurung brought claims for unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal against Amazon Services UK Ltd. The employment tribunal in Bristol dismissed both claims, finding that the dismissal was both substantively and procedurally fair.

Step by step

How an employment tribunal claim works

Most claims at work, such as unfair dismissal or discrimination, follow the same path. Strict time limits apply at each stage.

  1. Acas early conciliation

    Before most claims can start, the worker must contact Acas. It offers free help to settle the dispute; if that does not work, Acas issues a certificate whose number goes on the claim form.

  2. The claim (ET1)

    The worker, now called the claimant, fills in the ET1 claim form, setting out what happened and what they are claiming. It must be made within a strict time limit.

  3. The response (ET3)

    The employer, now called the respondent, has 28 days to reply on the ET3 form, saying whether it disputes the claim and why.

  4. Preliminary hearing

    Often a judge holds a shorter hearing first, to agree what the case is about, set a timetable, and sometimes decide a single point, such as whether the claim was made in time.

  5. Final hearing

    Both sides give evidence and can be questioned, before an employment judge who sometimes sits with two non-lawyer members. Hearings are usually open to the public.

  6. Judgment

    The tribunal decides whether each complaint succeeds. It may say so on the day or in writing later, and written decisions are published on GOV.UK.

  7. Remedy

    If the claim succeeds, the tribunal decides what the employer must do: usually pay compensation. This is sometimes decided at a separate remedy hearing.

  8. Appeal to the EAT

    Either side can appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal, but only on a point of law, not because they disagree with the facts the tribunal found. The deadline is usually 42 days from when the written reasons were sent.

Jargon buster

Jargon buster: tribunal words from A to Z

The legal words you will meet in the case reports, each in one plain line.

  • Acas: The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service: a free, impartial public body that advises on problems at work and helps employers and workers settle disputes.
  • Acas uplift: An increase of up to 25% in compensation when an employer unreasonably failed to follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
  • Aggravated damages: Extra compensation when the employer behaved in a high-handed, malicious or oppressive way that made the hurt worse.
  • Basic award: The part of unfair dismissal compensation worked out from age, length of service and weekly pay, in the same way as statutory redundancy pay.
  • Claimant: The person who brings the claim, usually the worker or former worker.
  • Compensatory award: The part of unfair dismissal compensation for the money actually lost, such as wages and pension, up to a legal limit.
  • Constructive dismissal: When an employee resigns because the employer seriously broke their contract, the law can treat the resignation as a dismissal.
  • Contributory fault: A cut in compensation because the employee's own blameworthy conduct helped bring about their dismissal.
  • Direct discrimination: Treating someone less favourably because of a protected characteristic, such as their age, disability, race, religion or belief, sex or sexual orientation.
  • Dismissed (of a claim): When a tribunal dismisses a claim, the claim has failed. This is not the same as being dismissed from a job.
  • Early conciliation: The first step for most claims: the worker must contact Acas, which offers to help both sides settle, before a tribunal claim can be made.
  • Employment Appeal Tribunal: The court that hears appeals against employment tribunal decisions, only on points of law, not on the facts.
  • Employment Judge: The legally qualified judge who runs the hearing and decides the case, sometimes with two non-lawyer members.
  • Employment tribunal: An independent judicial body that decides disputes between workers and employers, such as unfair dismissal and discrimination claims.
  • ET1 and ET3: The ET1 is the form a worker uses to start a tribunal claim; the ET3 is the form the employer uses to reply.
  • Gross misconduct: Behaviour serious enough for an employer to dismiss someone straight away, without notice.
  • Harassment: Unwanted conduct related to a protected characteristic, or of a sexual nature, that violates someone's dignity or creates an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.
  • Injury to feelings: Compensation for the upset and distress caused by discrimination.
  • Liability: Whether the employer is legally responsible: in other words, whether the claim succeeds.
  • Polkey reduction: A cut in compensation when the tribunal finds the employee would probably have been dismissed anyway, even if a fair process had been followed.
  • Preliminary hearing: An earlier, shorter hearing to settle arrangements or decide a single point, such as whether a claim was brought in time.
  • Protected characteristic: One of the nine things the Equality Act 2010 protects: age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation.
  • Reasonable adjustments: Changes an employer must make so that a disabled worker is not put at a substantial disadvantage, such as different hours, duties or equipment.
  • Remedy: What the tribunal orders when a claim succeeds, usually compensation.
  • Respondent: The employer, or other person or organisation, the claim is made against.
  • Strike out: Ending a claim, or an employer's defence, without a full hearing: for example because it has no reasonable prospect of success or has not been pursued.
  • TUPE: The rules that protect employees when the business or service they work in moves to a new employer: their jobs and terms move with them.
  • Unfair dismissal: Being dismissed without a fair reason, or in an unfair way. Most employees need to have worked for a minimum period to claim it.
  • Unlawful deduction from wages: Taking money out of someone's pay without the right to, or not paying wages that were due.
  • Vento bands: The guideline ranges (lower, middle and upper) tribunals use to set injury to feelings awards; the amounts in them go up each year.
  • Victimisation: Treating someone badly because they complained about discrimination, or helped someone else who did.
  • Well-founded: The tribunal's phrase for a claim that succeeds. "Not well-founded" means it fails.
  • Whistleblowing: Reporting certain kinds of wrongdoing at work in the public interest, such as danger to health and safety or a breach of the law. The law protects whistleblowers from dismissal and bad treatment for it.
  • Wrongful dismissal: Dismissal in breach of contract, usually without the notice, or notice pay, the employee was owed.
Earlier case notes

Earlier case notes: employment tribunals

Mrs Rachel Wright-Turner v London Borough of Hammersmith & Fulham: Record-Breaking £4.6 Million Disability Discrimination Award

Mrs Rachel Wright-Turner was awarded £4.6 million in one of the largest employment tribunal awards ever made in the UK. Wright-Turner, who worked as Director of Public Services Reform, suffered from ADHD and PTSD following her work supporting Grenfell Tower fire victims. The Council extended her probationary period while she was on sick leave without consultation, then dismissed her without explanation or opportunity to appeal. The tribunal found the Council had discriminated against her, harassed her, and senior officers including the Chief Executive had deliberately misled the tribunal by backdating documents. The award included loss of earnings, pension losses, injury to feelings, psychiatric injury, aggravated damages, exemplary damages of £15,000, and £271,000 for non-compliance with ACAS codes.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Ms A Obiagwu v Mr A Greystoke and Pantheon International Advisors Ltd: £20,000 Injury-to-Feelings Award for Sex Harassment

Ms Obiagwu succeeded in a claim of harassment related to sex under the Equality Act 2010. While her direct sex discrimination allegation was dismissed, the tribunal upheld that she had been subjected to unlawful harassment. At the remedies stage, the judge placed the injury-to-feelings award at the upper end of the middle Vento band, awarding £20,000, with interest added (taking the total to £21,437.81). The judgment provides a useful example of how tribunals separate discrimination findings from harassment findings, and how the Vento bands are applied on compensation even where only part of a case succeeds.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Mr R Assan v Vigilant Security (Scotland) Ltd (t/a Croma Vigilant): £233k Net Award (Plus Grossing-Up) After Victimisation and Unfair Dismissal Findings

This is a remedies judgment setting out a substantial compensation package following liability findings that included victimisation and unfair dismissal. The tribunal calculated extensive heads of loss including past and future loss of earnings, pension loss, injury to feelings (£25,000), and personal injury damages (£15,000), with interest applied. It also imposed an ACAS uplift of 17.5%, reflecting failures to follow appropriate procedures. The total net award shown is £233,262.83, with additional grossing up for tax displayed in the schedule, producing a grand total of £360,705.36. It’s a strong example of how awards can grow rapidly once multiple loss categories, uplift and tax treatment are applied.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Mrs Katrina Hibbert v The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police: £1.1 Million Award for Side-Hustle Discrimination

Katrina Hibbert, a safeguarding sergeant with Thames Valley Police, was awarded £1,176,368 after being constructively dismissed for disability discrimination. Hibbert suffered from complex PTSD, anxiety, and depression due to the emotionally intense nature of her work with child exploitation victims. Following occupational health advice, she set up a party tent business as a therapeutic outlet with the force's approval. When she was signed off sick with stress in 2019, Thames Valley Police withdrew her business permission without medical consultation, claiming it was "unsuitable to be running an active business whilst unable to fulfil obligations to your employer." The force then launched gross misconduct proceedings against her. The tribunal found that withdrawing the permission removed a crucial reasonable adjustment and constituted disability discrimination, ultimately forcing her resignation.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Rob Ogden v Booker Ltd: Unfair Dismissal in "Toxic" Workplace Culture

Rob Ogden, a delivery driver who had worked for Booker since 2016, was dismissed for gross misconduct after using offensive language towards a female colleague during a conversation about weight loss. Ogden admitted calling the colleague a "fing m" and making derogatory comments. However, the Manchester Employment Tribunal found the dismissal unfair, describing the workplace as having a "toxic" and "lawless" culture with no real enforcement of dignity at work standards by managers. The tribunal noted that widespread inappropriate "banter" and pranks were tolerated, and that Ogden had never been pulled up on such behavior before, giving him a false sense of security. The tribunal concluded that while Ogden's language was offensive, a written warning would have been more appropriate given the context of the dysfunctional workplace culture where managers were "complicit in that dysfunction."

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Nadine Hanson v Interaction Recruitment Specialists Ltd: Constructive Dismissal After Manager Ignored Greetings

Nadine Hanson won her unfair dismissal claim after her new managing director, Andrew Gilchrist, ignored her greetings on three occasions. Hanson, who had worked for the company for 20 years, arrived late after a medical appointment in September 2023 and attempted to greet Gilchrist three times without response. When she tried to show him proof of her appointment, he pushed her phone aside and suggested she leave. Within an hour, he emailed her direct reports offering them pay rises without consulting her. The Leeds Employment Tribunal ruled that while ignoring greetings alone may not constitute a fundamental breach, it contributed significantly to breaching the implied term of trust and confidence. Judge Sarah Davies found Gilchrist's evidence "unconvincing" and noted he had quickly formed negative opinions about Hanson without proper discussion about her work. Hanson resigned two weeks later due to anxiety, sleepless nights, and feeling humiliated and undervalued.

Read the decision on GOV.UK (PDF)

Meliesha Jones v Vale Curtains and Blinds: Admin Worker Unfairly Dismissed After Accidental Customer Email

Meliesha Jones, an administrator at Vale Curtains and Blinds, was unfairly dismissed after accidentally sending an email to a customer rather than forwarding it to a colleague. Jones received an email from a customer she found difficult and wrote to a colleague: "Can you change this… he's a twat so it doesn't matter if you can't." She accidentally clicked 'reply' instead of 'forward,' sending it directly to the customer. Upon realizing her mistake, Jones immediately apologized and offered to pay the customer £500 from her own money as a goodwill gesture. When the customer's wife complained and threatened to go to the press and post online, Jones was dismissed. The tribunal found her dismissal unfair, ruling that the investigation was inadequate and the decision to dismiss fell outside the band of reasonable responses, particularly given her clean disciplinary record and immediate remorse.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Professor Jo Phoenix v The Open University: £ Undisclosed Settlement for Gender Critical Beliefs Discrimination

Professor Jo Phoenix, a criminology professor at the Open University, won her discrimination claim after being harassed for her gender critical beliefs. Phoenix co-founded the Gender Critical Research Network, an academic research group, which led to a sustained campaign against her by colleagues. She was compared by her Deputy Head of Department to "the racist uncle at the Christmas dinner table" and subjected to an online open letter that encouraged a "pile-on" from others. The tribunal found Phoenix had been directly discriminated against and harassed, and that the University failed to protect her from attacks by colleagues for fear of being seen to support gender critical beliefs. The University delayed dealing with her grievance and terminated the process after she resigned, which constituted post-employment victimisation. Phoenix was awarded compensation (amount undisclosed but settled), and the tribunal ruled her constructive dismissal was both unfair and discriminatory.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Roz Adams v Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre: £69,000 for Gender Critical Beliefs Discrimination

Roz Adams, a counsellor at Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre, was awarded £69,000 after being constructively dismissed due to her gender critical beliefs. Adams believed that survivors of male sexual violence should be able to choose whether to engage with male or female counsellors. She questioned an email about a colleague that described them using they/them pronouns, asking for clarity on how to respond if service users asked if the colleague was male. This led to a deeply flawed disciplinary investigation where senior management believed her views were "inherently hateful." The tribunal's judgment was highly critical, calling the description of Adams' email as "humiliating and transphobic" as "nonsense" and stating the colleague's reaction had been "completely overblown." The tribunal ruled the investigation should never have been launched and was "clearly motivated by a strong belief that the claimant's views were inherently hateful." The disciplinary process was described as "completely spurious and mishandled."

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Rachel Meade v Westminster City Council and Social Work England: £58,000 for Gender Critical Beliefs Harassment

Rachel Meade, a social worker, was awarded over £58,000 including aggravated and exemplary damages after being harassed for her gender critical beliefs expressed on her private Facebook profile. A colleague complained to Social Work England (SWE) that Meade's posts were transphobic, leading to a fitness to practice investigation. Meade was told to either accept a one-year warning or face a hearing. Under pressure and fearing job loss, she accepted despite her immediate managers having no concerns about her practice. Westminster City Council then suspended her on gross misconduct charges, with the disciplinary investigation taking a year to complete and resulting in a final written warning. The tribunal found none of the Facebook posts were transphobic but were legitimate manifestations of Meade's protected belief. The tribunal ruled that both the Council and SWE had impeded her right to freedom of expression and harassed her through prolonged and unjustified processes.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Mr Richardson v West Midlands Trains Ltd: £42,000 for Unfair Dismissal Over Workplace Pranks

Train driver Mr Richardson was awarded £42,000 for unfair and wrongful dismissal after being sacked for placing a tarantula exoskeleton and later a snakeskin in a colleague's pigeonhole as workplace pranks. Richardson intended the pranks to elicit harmless surprise and lighthearted reactions. However, the company dismissed him for gross misconduct. The tribunal found that while Richardson's actions were "childish," they did not warrant termination. The judge ruled that the dismissal for what was intended as harmless workplace humor was disproportionate, particularly given there was no evidence of malicious intent or previous similar conduct. The tribunal emphasized that the sanction of dismissal was outside the range of reasonable responses available to the employer for such behavior.

Read the decision on GOV.UK

Dr Nigel MacLennan v The British Psychological Society: Landmark Whistleblowing Protection for Trustees

Dr Nigel MacLennan, President-Elect and trustee of the British Psychological Society (BPS), brought a whistleblowing claim after being expelled from his membership in May 2021. MacLennan believed the expulsion was retaliatory for reporting concerns about the organization. Initially, the Employment Tribunal dismissed his claim, ruling that unpaid charity trustees did not qualify for whistleblowing protection under UK law. However, in October 2024, the Employment Appeal Tribunal overturned this decision in a landmark ruling. The EAT argued that trustees, because of their significant responsibilities, should be considered to have "occupational status" and therefore qualify for whistleblowing protection. This decision potentially extends legal protections to over one million trustees across the UK, marking a significant development in employment law and governance for the charitable sector.

Source: available on EAT and tribunal websites

Tesco Stores Ltd v USDAW: Supreme Court Blocks "Fire and Rehire" Strategy

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of USDAW (Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers), preventing Tesco from dismissing workers as part of a "fire and rehire" strategy designed to remove employees' rights to retained pay. The case stemmed from a dispute over Tesco employees who had been promised retained pay as part of their contracts in exchange for staying with the business during a challenging period. Tesco sought to terminate these contracts to strip employees of this benefit, arguing it had served its purpose. The Supreme Court found that the right to retained pay was a permanent contractual entitlement and could not be removed through dismissal and re-engagement without breaching the agreement. The Court reinstated an injunction preventing Tesco from dismissing the employees, emphasizing that contractual terms cannot be unilaterally altered simply to remove benefits, setting an important precedent against fire and rehire practices.

Source: Supreme Court judgment available on BAILII

How we choose


We want to be open about this. We report only cases where the claimant won at least part of their claim.

Realistically, most employment tribunal claims never reach a decision we can report. Many are settled, often with help from Acas, and settlements are private. Many others are withdrawn before a hearing. Of the decisions that are published, a lot are short rulings on procedure, and many claims that do reach a hearing fail.

We cannot report on the cases that settle or are withdrawn, so we focus on the cases where someone won, because those show what the law protects and where an employer got it wrong.




"Editor's note: This database is maintained as a public resource for understanding UK employment and civil litigation precedents. Cases are selected based on legal significance and public interest."